Every measurement in a knitting pattern depends on one thing: the gauge. If you knit more or fewer stitches per 10 cm than the pattern says, the garment gets a different size, even if you follow every row exactly. That can be a problem, but it can also be a tool. Here is how to think about it, and how to calculate it.
Why gauge decides the size
A pattern tells you how many stitches to cast on, not how many centimetres to knit. The designer has worked out the stitch counts from the gauge. Change the gauge, and the same number of stitches covers a different width.
Say the body of a sweater has 200 stitches and the pattern gauge is 20 stitches per 10 cm:
| Your gauge (sts per 10 cm) | Width of 200 stitches | Difference |
|---|---|---|
| 18 | 111 cm | +11 cm |
| 20 (pattern) | 100 cm | – |
| 22 | 91 cm | –9 cm |
Just one stitch more or less per 10 cm changes the width by about 5%. On an adult sweater that is often 5 cm or more around the chest, which is the difference between two sizes.
The formula
To find the finished width at your gauge:
New measurement = the pattern's measurement × pattern gauge ÷ your gauge
Example: a sweater that measures 100 cm in the pattern at 20 stitches, knitted at 22 stitches:
100 × 20 ÷ 22 = 91 cm
Use stitches per 10 cm for both gauges. Measure your own gauge on a washed and dried swatch, and count half stitches too – 21.5 stitches is not the same as 22.
The same logic applies to length, using rows instead of stitches. In practice, length is usually easier: most patterns tell you to knit until a piece measures a certain number of centimetres, so you simply keep knitting until you reach it. Only the parts worked over a set number of rows change, such as a yoke, raglan increases or short-row shaping. If your row gauge is tighter, those parts get shorter; if it is looser, they get longer.
The pattern's gauge is a recommendation
Sometimes you change your gauge not because of a different yarn, but simply because you like the fabric better. The pattern's gauge might give a fabric that feels too stiff for your taste, or too loose and airy. A tighter gauge gives a firmer fabric with crisp stitches that holds its shape well. A looser gauge gives a softer, airier fabric with more drape.
Think of the pattern's gauge as the designer's recommendation, not a rule. What matters most is that you are happy with the fabric: how it feels, how it drapes and how it looks. Knit a couple of swatches on different needle sizes, wash them and choose the one you like best. Then use the formula above to pick the size that gives you the measurements you want.
Using it on purpose: knit a different size
Once you know the formula, you can knit a pattern in a thinner or thicker yarn on purpose, by choosing a different size. Here is a real example.
The Ankers Tröja by PetiteKnit is written for Filcolana Peruvian at 20 stitches per 10 cm. In size 9–12 months it measures 63 cm around the chest. Say you want to knit it in Filcolana Pernilla instead, and your swatch gives 22 stitches per 10 cm.
-
Size 9–12 months at your gauge
63 × 20 ÷ 22 = 57 cm
Too small - that is closer to the 6-9 months size. -
Work backwards: which pattern size gives 63 cm at your gauge?
63 × 22 ÷ 20 = 69 cm -
Choose the nearest size: size 2-3 years measures 70 cm in the pattern.
70 × 20 ÷ 22 = 64 cm
That is very close to the 63 cm you wanted.
So you follow the stitch counts for size 2-3 years, but the lengths for size 9-12 months. Knit the body and sleeves to the centimetres given for the smaller size, and check the yoke depth as you go, since it is worked over a set number of rounds in the larger size.
How much yarn do you need?
Yarn amounts are the hardest part to calculate exactly, because a different yarn, gauge and size all change how many metres go into each stitch. My rule of thumb: start from the metres for the size whose stitch counts you follow, then buy one extra ball.
In the example above, size 2-3 years takes 300 g of Peruvian (100 m per 50 g). Pernilla has 175 m per 50 g.
300 ÷ 50 × 100 = 600 m
600 ÷ 175 = 3.4, rounded up to 4 balls
4 + 1 extra = 5 balls
Because you knit the shorter lengths of the smaller size, you will probably have some left over rather than run short. Read more in How Much Yarn Do You Need for a Sweater?
When changing gauge works - and when it doesn't
Changing gauge works best for simple shapes: stocking stitch, ribbing, raglan and round-yoke sweaters, and roomy fits. Be more careful with:
- Colourwork and lace. The motifs stay the same number of stitches, so they get bigger or smaller with the gauge. A chart that fits neatly around a yoke may not fit once you change size.
- Fitted garments. When there is little ease, a few centimetres make a big difference to the fit.
- Very different yarns. A thin yarn knitted loosely to reach a thicker gauge gives a limp, see-through fabric. A thick yarn knitted tightly gets stiff. Your swatch should feel good, not just measure right.
If you are only one stitch off, try changing your needle size first. That is often all it takes. If you want to swap yarn rather than change gauge, read How to Substitute Yarn in a Pattern, and use the Yarn Weight Guide to compare thicknesses.
Quick checklist
- Knit a swatch of at least 15 × 15 cm, wash it and let it dry.
- Count stitches and rows over 10 cm, half stitches included.
- Calculate: pattern measurement × pattern gauge ÷ your gauge.
- Choose the size whose new measurement is closest to what you want.
- Knit the lengths in centimetres for the size you want to end up with.
- Calculate the yarn in metres for the size whose stitch counts you follow, and add a ball.
Not sure about your calculation? Bring your swatch and the pattern to the shop in Borrby or send me an email, I am happy to help you work it out.