How to Substitute Yarn in a Pattern

Yes, you can almost always knit a pattern in a different yarn than the one the designer used, as long as the new yarn matches the original in three ways: thickness and gauge, metres per gram, and fibre. Get those three right, knit a swatch, and you can choose any colour or yarn you like.

Here is how I go about it, step by step, with a real calculation from one of the patterns we sell.

Step 1: Find the original yarn's details

Start with the pattern. Most patterns list everything you need under materials:

  • Yarn name and how many grams are needed in each size
  • Metres per 50 g (or per ball)
  • Needle size
  • Gauge stitches and rows per 10 x 10 cm, and in which stitch

If the pattern only gives the yarn name, look the yarn up online or check a ball band. Write the details down, you will need them in the next steps.

Step 2: Match the gauge and thickness

The new yarn needs to knit up to the same gauge as the original, otherwise the measurements of the finished garment will be wrong. A good first check is the yarn weight class (fingering, DK, worsted and so on). My Yarn Weight Guide explains them all.

The best quick check, though, is metres per 50 g. Two yarns with similar metres per 50 g are usually about the same thickness. As a rule of thumb, a difference of up to roughly 10 % is often workable, but it is a guide, not a guarantee, the swatch has the final say.

Also compare the recommended needles and gauge on the ball bands. If they overlap with what the pattern asks for, you are on the right track.

Step 3: Calculate how much yarn you need

Never swap yarn gram for gram. Yarns of the same thickness can weigh very differently, so always calculate in metres:

  1. Total metres = grams in the pattern ÷ 50 × metres per 50 g of the original yarn
  2. Balls of the new yarn = total metres ÷ metres per ball of the new yarn – always round up

Here is a real example. The Fisherman Cardigan from our Filcolana patterns is knitted with one strand of Filcolana Peruvian. Say you want to knit it in Gepard Woolia instead:

Original: Filcolana Peruvian Substitute: Gepard Woolia
Fibre 100% wool (Peruvian highland wool) 100% organic merino wool
Metres per 50 g 100 m 132 m
Ball band needles and gauge 4.5–5 mm, 16–20 sts per 10 cm 4–6 mm, 15–19 sts per 10 cm
Pattern, size M 750 g –
Total metres 750 ÷ 50 × 100 = 1,500 m 1,500 m
Balls needed 15 balls of 50 g 1,500 ÷ 132 = 11.4, so 12 balls of 50 g

This is exactly why you should never swap gram for gram. Woolia has about 30% more metres per 50 g, so you need 12 balls instead of 15. Buying by weight would leave you with three balls too many.

Woolia is also a good reminder that metres per 50 g is only a guide. Despite the extra length, its ball band gives about the same gauge as Peruvian, because Woolia is a light, airy yarn. The pattern asks for 20 stitches per 10 cm in double moss stitch on 4 mm needles, which is at the firm end of Woolia's range, so knit a swatch and be ready to go down a needle size. Woolia is merino rather than highland wool, so expect a slightly softer, smoother cardigan.

If you are lengthening the body or sleeves, or are between sizes, it is wise to add a ball. You can read more about estimating yardage in How Much Yarn Do You Need for a Sweater?

Step 4: Think about fibre

Two yarns can have the same thickness and still behave very differently. Fibre affects warmth, elasticity, drape, weight and whether the garment grows over time:

  • Wool is elastic, warm and holds its shape well, a forgiving choice for most sweaters.
  • Superwash merino is smooth and soft, but it is often less springy than untreated wool and can grow a little when washed.
  • Alpaca is very warm and soft, heavier and less elastic than wool, so larger garments can lengthen with wear.
  • Mohair is light and warm with a fluffy halo that softens stitch definition.
  • Cotton and linen are cool, heavy and have almost no elasticity, which gives a fabric with a lovely drape but less bounce in ribbing.

The closer the fibre is to the original, the closer your garment will look and feel to the one in the pattern photos. My guide to yarn fibres goes into more detail.

Step 5: Always knit a swatch

A swatch is the only way to know for sure. Knit a square of at least 15 x 15 cm in the stitch the gauge is given in, then wash and dry it exactly as you will wash the finished garment. Many patterns give the gauge measured after washing, and some yarns change a lot in the wash.

Measure the stitches and rows over 10 cm in the middle of the swatch. Too many stitches? Go up a needle size. Too few? Go down a needle size. Knit a new swatch until it matches, and check that you like the fabric, too. A fabric that is too stiff or too loose will not get better in a full garment.

Holding yarns together

Many modern patterns are knitted with two yarns held together, and that opens up more options. Two thin yarns can replace one thicker yarn, and a thin companion thread can be added for softness and halo.

Some examples from our Filcolana patterns: Quiet Moments is knitted with one strand of Arwetta and one strand of Tilia held together, to 22 stitches per 10 cm on 4 mm needles. On its own, Arwetta knits up to 28–32 stitches on 2.5–3 mm needles. Heartline uses Peruvian with a strand of Alva, to 17 stitches per 10 cm on 5 mm needles.

Two strands do not simply double the thickness, and they do not move you a fixed number of weight classes. How much thicker the result is depends on the yarns, especially when one of them is a fluffy mohair or alpaca. So treat any combination as a new yarn: check the pattern's gauge, knit a swatch and calculate the metres for each strand separately.

Popular swaps

Looking for a substitute for a specific yarn? These guides compare the closest alternatives in our range:

Find your yarn

Browse all our yarns and compare metres per 50 g, needles and gauge with your pattern. You will find more guides on our Yarn School page. And if you are unsure, just ask me in the shop or send me an email with the pattern, I am always happy to help you find a good substitute.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.